![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses images 14 1 1 1 1 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3301 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Feverishing working in the kitchen to replicate dishes at the Eleven Madison Park tribute dinner Monday at Brookstreet hotel.
FEB 24 12 – 12:01 AM — I have mixed feelings about “tribute dinners” where chefs pay homage to the world’s culinary greats by serving replicas of their cuisine, on the assumption not everyone can travel for — much less score — reservations at some of the most sought-after tables on Earth.
As fun as tributes may be, I wonder whether Ottawa chefs are really best served by plating derivatives when there is so much creativity and originality bursting in kitchens across our nation’s capital.
While professionals in any field may admire the work of others — as, say, a student learns from the master, or a Food writer may savour the prose of A.J. Liebling — is imitation (even occasionally) a sincere form of flattery, or is it just presumptuous? Does a road show that plays for a week in Ottawa offer the same theatrical experience as the original that enjoyed critical acclaim in London?
It can be argued both ways; hence, my ambivalence.
Tribute dinners are not new to Ottawa, or larger cities like Chicago for that matter. In September, Ottawa saw two of them, one after the other, replicating the ground-breaking cuisine of chef Ferran Adria of el Bulli, the famous restaurant in Roses, Spain, that served its last meal in July 2011. Even before el Bulli was closed, dinner reservations in Catalonia were virtually impossible to get, to the frustration of literally millions the world over who never even had a chance.
The el Bulli tributes quickly sold out at Atelier and Navarra restaurants, both collaborative efforts by respective (and talented) Ottawa chef/owners Marc Lepine and Rene Rodriguez, who presented 15-course dinners at over $100 per person. They were by all accounts a success, offering Ottawans probably their only chance — ever – to taste what all the el Bulli fuss was about.
More recently, in November chef Murray Wilson, 27, at Atelier, who has an impressive pedigree of his own working in some of the best kitchens in the United Kingdom, piloted an ambitious effort to present a 16-course homage to the cuisine of three-Michelin-star Eleven Madison Park in New York City, the crown jewel in restaurateur Danny Meyer’s dining empire. In fact, Wilson had staged there last fall.
For the Eleven Madison dinner, Ottawa chefs were armed with a six-pound, 384-page road map in the just-released cookbook Eleven Madison Park by executive chef Daniel Humm (photo, left) and general manager Will Guidara — a completely off-the-charts, detailed and intricate work two years in the making, where convoluted recipes require specialized equipment such as sous vide immersion circulators, plastic vacuum-pack machines, liquid nitrogen, and techniques so advanced they are best left to professionals with lots of staff working free on stages.
Among those who came away impressed by the first Eleven Madison tribute was Kyle Chrisfferson, 28, chef de cuisine at Brookstreet hotel, who asked his boss, executive chef Clifford Lyness, if he and Wilson could put on a similar culinary show at the hotel’s Perspectives restaurant. Months of planning and days of intense preparation later, that’s exactly what unfolded Monday when a small platoon of about 10 chefs served an elaborate 16-course menu straight from the lavish pages of Eleven Madison Park that was so ambitious, so finicky, and so precise it took 34 diners more than five hours to wade through it all.
Dinner cost $125, with optional wine pairings at $75 extra. I can’t imagine how anyone made money from it.
Right, chef de cuisine, Perspectives, Kyle Christofferson; Atelier cook Murray Wilson; Brookstreet executive chef Clifford Lyness.
Why the sequel?
“It’s a fun event, it’s February and it generates some interest when we’re in a quieter month,” Lyness says.
“Kyle and Murray approached me and I said yes. The cookbook is great, Eleven Madison Park is phenomenal and it’s a definite challenge. It keeps my cooks engaged. We don’t do this many courses at once with such intricacy.”
Christofferson says Monday’s menu followed the cookbook “as precisely as we can.” He and Wilson enlisted help from executive chef Michael Hay of The Courtyard restaurant, Montreal pastry chef Josie Weitzenbauer, Katie Desormeaux of Atelier, and wine pairing by Brookstreet sommelier Rene Wallis, among others.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3271 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
L-R above, Murray Wilson of Atelier and chef Michael Hay of The Courtyard restaurant use liquid nitro to recreate pea lollipops with mint at the Eleven Madison Park tribute dinner Monday. As always, liquid nitro makes a good show.
“There have only been three or four substitutions where it’s near impossible to get an ingredient like, say, amethyst clusters, so we omitted it,” Christofferson says. “But we wanted to pass the experience of Eleven Madison Park to our guests.
“It’s not every day we get a chance to cook like this. It requires more logistics, more planning, and the attention to detail is impeccable. It’s a real challenge for chefs.”
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3255 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Above, a delightful Eleven Madison classic served at Perspectives on Monday: Strawberry Gelée on Foie Gras Terrine served on Black Pepper Sablé (almond flour biscuit). As delicious as it was beautiful.
Wilson says Eleven Madison Park is his favourite restaurant “in the entire world,” and that’s reason enough to share the experience. Again.
“We did a tribute for 15 people at Atelier last November and it went amazing. This time, Kyle invited me to work with him on a second tribute dinner. There are so many outstanding recipes in the book it was difficult to choose 16 courses.
“We’re not recreating just the food, we’re attempting to recreate the whole experience right down to the background music, the plates, the atmosphere, the attention to detail and all those small touches,” Wilson says.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3278 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
One of many highlights, pea lollipops made with pea ice cream, mint-infused cocoa butter with nitrogen-frozen chopped peas for texture. Richly surprising, and a great show in the dining room with nitrogen mist cascading from a tabletop vessel to the floor.
As you might expect, the Eleven Madison Park Tribute, Part II, was memorable on many levels. Certainly the plates — all 16 of them, or 17 if you count four dry cheese gougères served at the start — were as pretty as any I’ve seen in the nation’s capital, and for the most part their myriad visual and textural components were executed deftly with exquisite attention to detail.
So much detail, in fact, that the logistics of complicated assembly might explain why every hot dish (save and except a bisque) arrived at the tables barely warm at best. And that was disappointing.
Some plates were inevitably more successful than others, but all were breath-taking in their beauty. And, as a footnote, I should add that I purchased the cookbook just to study at home and follow along … Rest assured, there’s not much in it I would make. Then again, I don’t do tribute dinners.
Among the courses:
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3288 1 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Avocado Roulade with Poached Langoustine, Greek Yogurt Sauce, Lobster Roe Oil, Dehydrated Lobster Roe and Wood Sorel.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3295 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Fantasy of Eggs: Poached Egg Yolk with Sea Urchin Bavarois (Bavarian cream/mousse) with Acadian Sturgeon Caviar, Buttermilk Dressing, Baby Gem Lettuce and Chives. Not one of my favourites, it was beautiful until the instant you broke the egg yolk, which puddled and made a quick mess of the plate.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3308 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
As pretty as cruciferous can be: Cauliflower Roasted with Grapes, Almonds and Curry, served with cauliflower couscous, carrot curry sauce and cauliflower purée with carrot, curry, ginger broth.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3312 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Squash Bisque (not shown) with Prawns: Spot prawns cooked sous vide seven minutes in beurre blanc served with butternut squash purée, glazed beans, pickled butternut squash, squash wedges and bacon crisps, finished with butternut bisque and toasted pumpkin seeds, pumpkin oil. Tasty, but I found the bisque too salty.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3322 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Foie Gras Torchon with Wild Boar, Figs and Juniper. Elegant, nicely executed with juniper berry crumble, minced butternut, squash spheres, pickled king eryngii mushrooms, red currants, Brussels sprout leaves, beets and fig pulp, finished with game vinaigrette. Creative blend of colour, texture.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3323 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Nova Scotia Bay Scallop Ceviche with Lemon Oil, Persimmon and Radish, pickled and compressed with nectarine vinaigrette, radish sprouts. Really, a remarkable and refreshing plate.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3328 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Nova Scotia Lobster Poached with Carrots and Vadouvan Granola (a French interpretation of curry). Poached in beurre blanc at 150 F 14 minutes, finished with citrus sabayon and cilantro. My least favourite dish of the night because the lobster, unfortunately, took on a gummy, almost glutinous and unpleasant texture. I wasn’t the only one who didn’t finish it.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3332 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Quail from Nipissing Farms, cooked sous vide at 145 F 15 minutes, seared and glazed with soy, orange purée with endive also coked sous vide with saffron, ginger, shallot, Port, medjool dates. Finished with date and quail jus with orange blossom water and phyllo allumette with orange juniper powder and espelette pepper. This was as satisfying, succulent, as it was pretty.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3337 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Guinea Fowl Roasted with Parsnip, Black Trumpet Mushroom, Oats: Fowl cooked sous vide 145 F 25 minutes, seared and brushed with brown butter, served with parsnip purée, riesling-poached grapes, sautéed trumpet mushrooms and oat crumble. Finished with dehydrated grapes, Guinea fowl sauce with emulsified foie gras, red verjus, red grapes. Again, an attractive and delectable dish.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3341 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Beef Tenderloin with Oxtail, Bone Marrow, Swiss Chard: Alberta tenderloin cooked sous vide at 145 F 25 minutes, rolled in thyme and garlic butter, topped with bone marrow crust. Served with crushed fingerling potatoes, oxtail braised in red wine and veal stock wrapped in Swiss chard, hedgehog mushrooms sautéed with thyme and garlic, finished with bordelaise sauce. The recipe calls for the sous-vide beef to be chilled, sliced, topped with marrow, then broiled under high heat one minute until golden; unfortunately, there was not much if any caramelization on my plate, which would have given the protein more depth and texture. The oxtail-stuffed chard, however, was delightfully rich and full-flavoured.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3344 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Kir Royale: Mimicking traditional flavours of Kir Royale in a Cassis sorbet with champagne foam, lemon gel and meringue on the bottom, sugar tuile on top. This was a brilliant, pretty, delicious, intense palate cleanser — certainly welcome after 13 intense savoury courses.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3346 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Study in hazelnut with pistachio tuile, chestnut pastry cream, chestnut bavarois (mousse), hazelnut meringues, hazelnut pavlovas, rehydrated raisins, riesling-poached white grapes, dehydrated grapes. A very busy plate, which I tasted and then passed to a dining companion who finished it handily after polishing off her own dessert. Sorry, I’m not a big fan of sweet courses, especially at 11 p.m. after sitting all night.
![A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses IMG 3348 A tribute to Eleven Madison Park: Mostly hits, but some misses]()
Chocolate and Milk: Caramelized white chocolate sorbet, dehydrated chocolate mousse, frozen chocolate foam, on top of dulce de leche and whipped crème fraîche, finished with browned milk solids and dehydrated milk foam. My friend happily ate this one too.
.